The Political Revolution

Was the Revolutionary War a real political revolution or simply a war for independence fought and won by the rebellious colonists who turned against their British cousins?

The war had begun as a fight for the rights of English citizens, became a fight for independence, and led to prolonged internal debate over the new forms of government for the new nation.

The conventional British model sought to balance monarchy, aristocracy, and the common people. The balance of these sectors of society would preserve individual liberties.  

Americans looked at this model and realized that their own society was more democratic than Britain and needed new political assumptions and institutions.

Nonetheless the new American government, as well as the governments in the various states, were deeply rooted in the colonial experience, the prevailing point of view of the Whigs, and the Enlightenment. Ideas such as the contract theory of government, the sovereignty of the people, the separation of powers, and natural rights were all important.

The idea of republican government was radical at the time of the Revolution. Americans were inspired by the radical elements of British Whiggery. Ideas of civic virtue from classical times were also influential.

Americans believed the Old World was corrupted by monarchs and aristocratic power. Hopeful Americans believed their revolution would usher in a new age of liberty and virtue unseen since classical times, not only for themselves, but for all peoples.

The assumption of power by the state assemblies was revolutionary in the following sense. Royal governors and officials left the states, Loyalists were kicked out of the assemblies, and the assemblies now full of Patriots assumed power illegally.

  Extensive political experimentation occurred at the state level between 1776 and 1778.

Written constitutions (a vague body of law and precedent was insufficient), governments of law, not men

Representative government

Bills of rights (religion, press, speech, assembly, fair trial by jury, equality before law)

Constitutional conventions in Massachusetts and New Hampshire

Limits on the powers of governors

Expansions of the power of legislatures

Separation of church and state (official churches in New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut)

The Massachusetts Constitution of 1780 declared:

  “The body politic is formed by a voluntary association of individuals; it is a social compact, by which the whole people covenants with each citizen, and each with the whole people that all shall be governed by certain laws for the common good.”